Shora
← All articles

Why does stress cause insomnia? The arousal that outlasts the day

Stress keeps your alert system switched on after dark, and worry about the stressor matters more than the stressor. What the research shows, and what helps.

Watercolor of a woman in a dark sweater sitting on a wooden dock by a moonlit lake, a folded blanket and a notebook beside her

Stress causes insomnia because sleep needs your alert system to stand down, and stress tells it to stay on guard. Stress hormones, a faster heart and a mind that keeps returning to the problem all signal that this is no time to go offline. Research also shows that how often you replay a stressor at night predicts sleep trouble better than how many stressful things happen to you.

Picture a week with a hard deadline. You get through the day on momentum. Then you turn off the light, your body is tired, and your head is still in the meeting you have tomorrow.

What stress does to the switch that lets you sleep

Falling asleep is less like pressing a button and more like a handover. During the day, systems that keep you alert and ready to act are in charge. At night they are supposed to hand control to the systems that bring sleep on. Stress interferes with that handover.

When you face pressure, your body releases adrenaline and cortisol. They raise heart rate, sharpen attention and put energy into your muscles. That is useful at 2 p.m. when you need to deal with a problem. It is a poor state for 11 p.m., when the same chemistry reads as "stay awake, something is wrong."

Sleep researchers have a name for this: hyperarousal. A 2010 review in Sleep Medicine Reviews pulled together hormonal, nervous system, brain wave and imaging studies and found that people with chronic insomnia show raised arousal both at night and during the day. The authors describe insomnia as the meeting point of three things: a built-in tendency toward arousal, a stressor that sets it off, and habits that keep it going.

That last part explains why stress-related sleep trouble can outlive the stress itself.

It is the replay, not the stressor

You might expect the number of bad things in your life to predict how badly you sleep. The research says it is more about your reaction to them.

A 2014 study of 2,316 adults who had never had insomnia asked them to count their stressful events and rate how much each one intruded on their thoughts. A year later, both counted, but intrusive thinking about the stressor was the stronger predictor of who had developed insomnia. Intrusion carried much of the effect of the stressful events themselves. People who reported that their sleep is easily disturbed by stress carried an extra risk.

An earlier 2003 study by Charles Morin's group tracked 67 people, 40 with insomnia and 27 good sleepers, for three weeks. Both groups reported about the same number of minor stressful events. The people with insomnia rated those events as having more impact, felt they had less control, and reported more arousal before bed. Arousal and coping style sat between daytime stress and nighttime sleep.

Your sleep is not hostage to your calendar. You often cannot remove the stressor this week. You can work on the replay, and on how keyed up your body is when you lie down.

Why it keeps going after the stress is over

Many people sleep badly during a stressful month, then recover once the month ends. Some do not, and the reason is usually a loop that forms along the way.

  1. Stress makes a few nights rough.
  2. You start to worry about sleep itself. "If I don't fall asleep in the next hour, tomorrow is ruined."
  3. That worry is a new stressor, and it shows up right at bedtime.
  4. You spend longer in bed awake, trying hard, and the bed starts to feel like the place where you lie awake.

By step four, the original problem may be gone. The arousal now belongs to the bedroom and the clock. This is why trying harder to sleep tends to backfire: effort is a form of arousal. Our guide on what to do when your mind won't stop at night covers that trap in more detail, so here the focus is on the stress side.

How to lower the arousal before bed

Forcing calm rarely works. Aim instead to give your body and mind fewer reasons to stay on watch. Pick one or two of these, not all of them.

Close the loops on paper

Unfinished tasks are a common source of bedtime replay. In a 2018 sleep laboratory study, 57 young adults spent five minutes before bed writing either a to-do list for the coming days or a list of things they had already finished. The to-do group fell asleep faster, and the more specific their lists, the faster they fell asleep. It was one night in healthy young people, so treat it as a promising, cheap experiment rather than a cure.

Write the tasks down with the first concrete step for each. "Email Dana the revised numbers" is better than "budget stuff."

Slow the breathing, lengthen the exhale

Breath is the part of the stress response you can steer on purpose. Breathing out more slowly than you breathe in leans the nervous system toward its calming side. A 2013 review of breathing practices in Psychiatric Clinics of North America found that breath work can ease symptoms of stress, anxiety and insomnia, and noted that it does not suit everyone.

Try this in bed:

  1. Breathe in through your nose for a count of four.
  2. Breathe out gently through your mouth for a count of six to eight.
  3. Keep it soft. If you feel lightheaded, shorten the exhale.
  4. Continue for five minutes, or until you stop counting.

If you prefer a set pattern, 4-7-8 breathing uses a short hold and a long exhale. Skip the hold if holding your breath makes you more anxious.

Release the tension you carry into bed

Stress often lives in the jaw, shoulders and hands. Progressive muscle relaxation works by tightening one muscle group for a few seconds and then letting it go, moving slowly through the body. In a 2021 trial with 60 undergraduates, 20 minutes of recorded muscle relaxation raised felt relaxation compared with a control group, and skin conductance and heart rate drifted steadily toward a calmer state during the session. It is graded Strong for evidence in our library. If you would rather not tense anything, a body scan for sleep moves attention through the body without the squeeze.

Build a buffer between work and bed

If stress follows you home, the gap between your last email and your pillow may be too short. A buffer of even 30 minutes with no work input gives arousal time to fall. Our post on unwinding after work has ideas for that stretch of the evening.

How Shora fits a stressful night

When you open Shora at night, the check-in asks how you feel through a mood, four dials or a few lines of writing, and then puts together a session for that state. Wired and tense calls for something different from tired and low, and the sleep preparation session draws on practices like a long-exhale breath and a body scan. The session asks afterward whether it helped, and that answer shapes what Shora suggests next time you feel the same way. It will not fix a month of bad nights on its own. You can download Shora and try the check-in free.

When to get more support

A few rough nights during a stressful stretch are common, and they usually settle when the pressure eases. Talk to a doctor if trouble falling or staying asleep happens at least three nights a week for three months, the threshold clinicians use for chronic insomnia, or sooner if it is wrecking your days.

The best-studied treatment is cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I), not a breathing exercise. A 2015 meta-analysis in Annals of Internal Medicine of 20 trials with 1,162 adults found CBT-I cut the time to fall asleep by about 19 minutes and time awake after first falling asleep by about 26 minutes, with gains that seemed to last. It is available from sleep clinics, some therapists and structured digital programs.

Also see a clinician if you snore loudly or stop breathing in your sleep, if you wake with dread most mornings, or if low mood and poor sleep have been feeding each other for weeks. If you are in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, call or text 988 in the US, or contact your local emergency services.